Public Interest Versus Private Greed (Rosemont Copper Mine)

Site of Rosemont copper mine (Photo credit: Arizona Mining Reform Coalition)

Site of Rosemont copper mine (Photo credit: Arizona Mining Reform Coalition)

Original post by Frances Causey, The Huffington Post

The refrain is all too common these days. The democratic and regulatory process circumvented in favor of big business interests at the expense of practically everything else. Think “Too Big To Fail Banks” — the big banks produced record profits last quarter and yet our banking system, regulated with a weak Dodds-Frank bill, has never been at greater risk of collapsing in a heap — with taxpayers picking up the tab if these behemoths fail.

Closer to home, southern Arizonans are dealing with a Canadian mining company, Augusta Resource Corporation, that is using its investors’ money to buy political support to acquire permits that would allow it to blast a one-mile wide, half-mile deep, open-pit copper mine in the Santa Rita Mountains south of Tucson. If the mine gets all of its permits and is approved, Augusta’s subsidiary, Rosemont Copper Company, will dump billions of tons of toxic mine waste burying some 4,000 acres of canyons, streams and prime wildlife habitat on the Coronado National Forest.

Rosemont is rushing to get its permits and a Record of Decision from the U.S. Forest Service before it runs out of money. But it’s not just money at stake in this fight but the public’s health. Two of the most contentious permits would allow Rosemont to pollute southern Arizona’s air and water supplies. Local ranchers, residents and business owners have long suspected that Rosemont has had, and continues to have, undue and inappropriate influence over the issuance of these permits.

And it’s no wonder. In 2011, a federal judge in Tucson confirmed those suspicions when he found that Rosemont and the U.S. Forest Service had been meeting secretly to discuss the critically important Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) that is suppose to analyze the mine’s environmental and economic impacts. In a written ruling, U.S. District Court Judge Frank R. Zapata found those meetings presented at the least an “appearance of impropriety.”

In recent weeks, new information has emerged revealing that Arizona regulators, ostensibly charged with protecting public health and safety, exchanged nearly three dozen emails with the governor’s office that could show inappropriate and impermissible political influence in deliberations over Rosemont’s air pollution permit. While that decision is supposed to be based only on technical and scientific public health information, the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) has admitted that it had been engaging in a “deliberative process” with Governor Jan Brewer’s office about the Rosemont air pollution permit — and that those deliberations had nothing to do with protecting public health. On the contrary, descriptions of the emails provided in legal briefs suggest they appear to deal with jurisdictional issues, drafting press releases, a briefing memo, and news articles.

Hearings recently began on an appeal by opponents of that air pollution permit. Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, the southern Arizona coalition that filed the appeal, will present experts and evidence showing that Rosemont received their air pollution permit by manipulating scientific data to hide potential violations of state and federal air pollution standards. If the previously secret emails show that the governor’s office and ADEQ violated the law that too will be introduced in evidence at the hearing.

But it doesn’t stop there. More evidence has emerged that when it comes to Rosemont Copper, an “appearance of impropriety” is business as usual. Coronado National Forest Supervisor Jim Upchurch, whose staff was participating in those closed-door meetings that a federal judge found suspect, admitted in a recent newspaper interview that he is trying to meet “the needs” of Rosemont Copper by rushing out an incomplete environmental impact analysis in order to issue its final Record of Decision before addressing public concerns about the mine.

The “needs” that Upchurch is trying to meet appear tied to Augusta Resource’s admission that if it doesn’t receive its permits by September 30, the company could run out of cash and its “ability to continue as a going concern” would be in jeopardy.

If it isn’t improper for the Forest Service — whose mission is to protect public lands, not foreign mining companies and their investors — to be cutting corners to meet Augusta’s “needs,” it’s hard to imagine what is.

However, one public agency, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, is doing the right thing. In a 2012 letter to Forest Supervisor Upchurch, the EPA called the Rosemont DEIS one of the worst it has ever reviewed and that the document underestimates the project’s negative environmental effects. The EPA says it believes the mining project should not proceed as proposed.

Across this country, Congress and state legislatures continue to gut the budgets of agencies that were created not only for the protection of our health but also to protect the public from unscrupulous and predatory companies like Rosemont Copper. As Arizonans, we ask every day why the rights of a speculative, foreign mining company are more important than the air we breathe? We would like to hear an answer on this issue from our public officials, whom we have entrusted with so much.

 

 

 

Posted in Biodiversity & Habitat Destruction, Mining & Drilling, Toxification | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Forest Service’s Environmental Report for Rosemont Mine Draws Fire from Pima County and Southern Arizona U.S. Representatives

Credit: Photo by Tom Vezo/Save the Scenic Santa Ritas via Earth Island Journal

Credit: Photo by Tom Vezo/Save the Scenic Santa Ritas via Earth Island Journal

Original article by Rosemont Mine Truth

The Coronado National Forest’s proposed final environmental impact study for the Rosemont copper mine is drawing sharp criticism from Pima County’s top administrator. and two U.S. Congressmen from southern Arizona.

Pima County is demanding that a new study be prepared in written comments submitted in response to the CNF’s proposed Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) for the massive copper mine.

“Relying upon this document for your decision as to whether to permit the mine’s destruction of thousands of acres of public Forest land, will surely result in lengthy challenges,” Pima County Administrator Chuck Huckelberry states in an Aug. 14 letter to the CNF Supervisor Jim Upchurch.

The proposed FEIS, Huckelberry states, “is still incomplete in many ways and lacks information required to be included in a Final EIS.”

U.S. Representatives Raul Grijalva and Ron Barber, meanwhile, sent a joint, Aug. 15 letterto Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack urging him to “ensure the Forest Service fully and completely analyze the impacts of this mining project.”

The Congressmen stated the Pima County has “stressed the importance of a thorough environmental impact study” and that the “concerns of Pima County and all local stakeholders are critical to ensuring any environmental evaluation is conducted correctly.”

The Congressmen noted that when the proposed FEIS was released on July 1, it was missing essential elements including analysis of endangered species impacts, consultation with Native American communities regarding impact to historical and cultural sites, Clean Water Act permits and responses to public comments.

“Because of this, we believe the Forest Service should take as much time as is needed in order to ensure a thorough and complete review,” Barber and Grijalva wrote.

The Final EIS that is ultimately released by the Forest Service will be used by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to determine whether to issue a Clean Water Act permit for the mine.

Huckelberry said that having the Corps rely on an inadequate FEIS in its decision on whether to issue a Clean Water Act permit allowing Rosemont to “fill, destroy and pollute area waterways, springs and seeps will also prove problematic.”

The mine cannot be built without the Clean Water Act permit. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has veto authority over Clean Water Act permits and has expressed serious concerns about the mine’s impact on Arizona’s waterways.

CNF Supervisor Jim Upchurch has stated in published reports that he wants to release the FEIS before new regulations take effect on Sept. 27 to meet the needs of Vancouver, B.C.-based Augusta Resource Corp. Augusta is seeking state and federal permits through its wholly-owned subsidiary, Rosemont Copper Company, to construct the mine in the Santa Rita Mountains on the CNF.

The new regulations would require at least 90 days of additional consultations between the Forest Service and mine opponents before the FEIS could be completed.  Cash-strapped Augusta stated in an Aug. 14 regulatory filing that a delay in issuing the FEIS until early next year would cost the company a minimum of $29 million.

The Congressmen’s letter to Vilsack criticized Upchurch’s efforts to “fast track” publication of the FEIS prior to new regulations in order to accommodate Augusta’s needs.

“The Forest Service promulgated these regulations for the explicit purpose of resolving conflicts prior to a decision and there is no need to avoid following them for this particular FEIS,” they wrote.

Pima County submitted more than 300 pages of comments to the proposed FEIS. The county was particularly concerned about the lack of mitigation that will be required to compensate for the massive environmental impact of the proposed mine.

Rosemont Mine Map

Huckelberry stated that the “level of mitigation proposed is inadequate to offset the significant adverse and irreversible permanent impacts” of the mine.

Pima County, he said, is very concerned that a “loophole big enough to drive a mine truck through it” in connection with mitigation could lead to a scenario “where the public will be left with a mess; and the taxpayers will be on the financial hook for corrective action.”

Posted in Biodiversity & Habitat Destruction, Mining & Drilling | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Black-Footed Ferret Recovery Effort Looking For Volunteers

Last opportunities of 2013 to help recover an endangered species

Original article by Independent Newsmedia, Inc. USA

August 16, 2013

SELIGMAN, Ariz. – The Arizona Game and Fish Department’s black-footed ferret recovery effort will be conducting the final two spotlighting efforts of 2013 and is looking for dedicated volunteers to assist.

The black-footed ferret, twice thought extinct, was reintroduced into Arizona’s Aubrey Valley in 1996. Each year Game and Fish conducts spotlighting efforts, which is the method used to document the population of this elusive, nocturnal, and endangered carnivore.

The Black-footed Ferret Recovery Project personnel are experimenting with a new method in 2013, conducting two shorter spotlighting efforts instead of five consecutive nights. The first fall spotlighting effort will be from Sept. 19-21 and the second from Oct. 17-19. Those wishing to assist can volunteer for just one evening or multiple nights.

The effort is held at the black-footed ferret recovery area, located west of Seligman.

“We had set a record with 185 volunteers in the spring,” said Jeff Pebworth, wildlife program manager at the Game and Fish Kingman office. “People staying involved in this effort is critical because we don’t have the personnel available to fully staff these events.”

In the last decade, black-footed ferrets in Aubrey Valley have reached a population high enough to be considered self-sustaining, meaning no captive-bred ferrets are needed to maintain a population. During the spring spotlighting effort 31 individual ferrets were captured and processed. An additional 57 ferrets were spotted, but not captured.

The reintroduction of these specialist carnivores in Arizona was possible because of the state’s Heritage Fund which, when matched with federal dollars, accounts for the project’s funding. This, along with the dedication of volunteers, has made Arizona’s reintroduction effort a model for other sites to emulate.

“To this point, the black-footed ferret is an amazing success story,” Mr. Pebworth said. “All the ferrets in the wild today are the offspring of just seven males and 11 females. Our crew, along with the dedicated volunteers, has played a critical role throughout the recovery process.”

Volunteers can witness the processing of the animals, which provides the information to document a minimum population, longevity, and movement throughout the range.

Volunteers must be able to stay attentive from sunset to sunrise and be willing to learn how to use a Global Positioning System (GPS). A parent or guardian must accompany any youth under 18.

“This is an opportunity to see the amount of effort involved with this reintroduction,” Mr. Pebworth said. “Not to mention the chance to see an animal few others have ever seen in the wild.”

Those wishing to volunteer, or needing more information, should e-mail azferret@azgfd.gov by Sept. 13 for the earlier effort and by Oct. 11 for the later opportunity. Write “Fall Spotlighting” with “September,” “October,” or “Both” in the subject line. Individuals should indicate which night(s) they are available to help; include a first and last name, a contact number, and if anyone else will be attending with them. Those without e-mail can call 928-422-0155.

Additional information will be sent following contact, including meeting location and times.

Volunteers should also note any of the following equipment they can bring: GPS, clipboard, headlamp, pen, binoculars, walkie-talkies, 4×4 vehicle (please list passenger capacity), compass, or a spotlight that is either rechargeable or can plug into a cigarette lighter.

It can be cool, so individuals need to dress appropriately.

“A lot of effort has been put forth in this reintroduction effort and we’ve seen positive results,” Mr. Pebworth said. “However, it is critical we continue to document ferret numbers and understand how this population is holding up in the wild.”

Posted in Listening to the Land | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Immigrant X Data Entry

A group called ‘Immigrant X’ infiltrated and sabotaged an immigration database, falsifying information about hundreds of undocumented immigrants:
 

anarachist

IMMIGRANT X DATA ENTRY

Original post by  on Friday, August 9, 2013, Immigrant

In the last month we managed to get a way into the hotlines of the immigration department where the public can inform on an “illegal immigrant”. We have teamed up with the PLU (Accidental Anarchist) an anarchist group that has helped us finding squats to house undocumented immigrants.  We managed to find the main temp agency hiring call centre workers and data entry clerks for the immigration departments call lines. Immigrant Y managed to keep a high level account to the immigration database alive for the last 2 months. This is giving us access to staff personnel records and hence the contract terms of employment and the temp agency  involved in call centre recruitment.

So here is how it works. Three members of the PLU got picked up by the temp agency the immigration department is using to hire call centre workers. From there two were assigned to perform data entry and make call backs on recorded messages and another member was given a job taking direct calls.

The plan was simply to make false data entries into the data base.  We simple replaced the informant data  with the “illegal immigrant” being informed on plus ensuring the “illegal immigrant” details were entered incorrectly (but similar).  Quite simple but it meant that we were able to make hundreds of false entries into the database. Immigrant Y created around 15 false accounts by reactivated temp staff accounts and creation of 5 fresh accounts. The PLU members could simply swap between these accounts when performing the data entry to ensure the data pollution was widespread across multiple accounts. This would mean if/when the false entries were detected a wide section of the data would be seen as suspect; basically all data entry at the call centre during before and after the PLU members employment. The reactivated accounts would also be seen as suspicious. Time and human resources by the immigration department would require the screening of data entry and all data would be seen as suspect shutting down this source of information used to target undocumented immigrants.

data entry

We took  precautions  of course and changed all the personal details of the three PLU members so they cannot be identified by their real names or contact details as soon as they were employed in the immigration employment records. The link between the temp agency and PLU member would be lost in the immigration database. The PLU members gave false social security data and bank and contact details to the temp agency.  Unfortunately they will never be paid for their work.

The three members of the PLU walked off the job today. We thought that if they stayed any longer that there would be a risk they would  be found out.  We estimate that the immigration department will have to follow up on at least several dozen false leads wasting their time and energy from the 10 days and creating raids on informants which we hope will have a educational impact for them.

The last part of the plan will to actually inform the immigration department that their database has been polluted. We are still weighing the risks as to whether we will take this last step. We would be interested of course to hear what you think.

Posted in Property & Material Destruction | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Group Rooted in the Desert Looks Out for Migrants

By , The New York Times
Published: August 2, 2013

ARIVACA, Ariz. — Monsoon rains tinge the desert with deceptive hints of green at this time of the year, but migrants crossing illegally from Mexico continue to risk death from thirst and exposure in the blazing heat. A fortunate few who become lost might stumble upon lifesaving gallon jugs of drinking water, scattered by a band of volunteers along makeshift footpaths that have been carved through the mountains and washes.

Arivaca mapFrom a primitive base camp here, volunteers trained by a group called No More Deaths patrol the desert, offering water, food, clothing and medical care to lost, injured and exhausted migrants, no questions asked. The group’s mission is as simple, though not uncontroversial: to end migrant deaths along Arizona’s borderlands.

On average, 144 gallons of water a week are carried out of the camp, where bathrooms are buckets equipped with toilet seats, and bedding is a sleeping bag stretched out on the dirt.

Byrd Baylor, 89, a best-selling children’s book author living on 35 acres here, had been helping migrants “get to where they need to go” for years, she said, by distributing food and water to those who crossed her land. A decade ago, she gave permission to No More Deaths to set up a base near her home — because, she explained, “we were all doing the same thing, more or less.”

For Ms. Baylor, helping migrants is an organic part of living in a remote corner of the desert. For the organization’s volunteers, it is serious business. The group, co-founded by a Presbyterian pastor whose church served as a sanctuary for Central Americans fleeing bloodshed in the 1980s, is made up of volunteers, mostly white and largely progressive, who are quick to criticize the intense focus on security at the border. Questions of citizenship and legal status seldom dominate the discussions here; compassion, they say, is their motivation.

“This is not about immigration,” Emrys Staton, 31, a volunteer since 2004, said one recent morning as he and four others traversed a wash. “It’s about saving lives.”

Summer is the deadliest season here, with its oppressive heat, and rivers can surge unexpectedly, sweeping away anyone trying to cross. Poisonous scorpions and rattlesnakes lurk. Loose rocks underfoot can cause a deadly tumble into canyons or crevices.

The group’s methods are meticulous, and Byrd Camp, as the base is known, functions as its launching pad.

Planning for the day begins the previous night, after the group shares a communal dinner that can be surprisingly tasty, like the curried garbanzo beans cooked by Mr. Staton, or simply a surprise, like the vegetarian lasagna that arrived unexpectedly on a recent Wednesday, donated by a church in Tucson.

Over the years, the group has mapped dozens of routes, bushwhacking through hills and valleys in search of hidden paths carved by migrants.

“Do you want to discuss a wake-up time?” one of the volunteers asked one night.

By 6 a.m. on Thursday, another volunteer was walking past the group’s camping tents, strumming a guitar and singing random lines from Taylor Swift songs.

By 7:30, the volunteers were traveling to water distribution points by car and by foot, breaking for a lunch of peanut butter sandwiches under a mesquite tree. At each drop spot, they counted the jugs they found: untouched, consumed and vandalized. There was speculation that some of the containers may have been damaged by Border Patrol agents, who have been caught on film dumping the water the volunteers have left behind.

In a statement, Customs and Border Protection, the Border Patrol’s parent agency, said that the agency did not tolerate misconduct, and that agents were appropriately disciplined whenever it was identified. The agency conducts “ongoing dialogue with humanitarian groups,” the statement said, and despite their different missions, “both sides are committed to reducing deaths in Arizona’s harsh desert environments.”

The Border Patrol has placed rescue beacons and warning signs in the desert, and broadcasts messages in Spanish across the border in an effort to discourage border crossers. Its elite search-and-rescue team often comes to aid migrants, like the nine Mexicans abandoned by their smuggler near Arivaca late last month, one of whom died before help arrived. (Later, the survivors were processed for deportation.)

No More Deaths volunteers recalled a time when border agents were sometimes stationed on a hill overlooking their camp, which migrants were likely to stumble upon if they followed a wash named Papalote. In 2009, some volunteers who were depositing water along a route through the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge were stopped by Border Patrol agents and cited for littering by another federal agency, the Fish and Wildlife Service. One man contested the charge before the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and in 2010, a panel of judges ruled, 2 to 1, that jugs of water were not garbage.

During a training session for new volunteers in Tucson last month, Maryada Vallet, a longtime member of the group, made its position clear. “We’re not there to sneak anything by the Border Patrol,” she said. But she emphasized that the Border Patrol was to be called for help only if a migrant requested it.

On the trails here, signs of migrant traffic can be found everywhere: an abandoned sneaker with a piece of carpet stapled to its bottom to prevent footprints; jugs of water made of black plastic, so that they do not reflect sunlight; empty packets of Isadora Bayos Frijoles, a Mexican brand of refried beans that travelers have carried for food.

Maggie Duffy, 21, an anthropology major at Notre Dame who was volunteering for the first time, spent part of one recent day reading coordinates from a GPS to Lydia Delphia, 21, as she steered a beat-up Dodge Ram known as Godzilla (because “it’s big and bad,” Ms. Delphia said) to trailheads west of Byrd Camp.

Another first-time volunteer, William Berk, a medical student at Brown, picked up the task in the afternoon. He played a Yeah Yeah Yeahs song on his iPhone as the truck rumbled on.

Volunteers must apply to spend time at Byrd Camp, which is usually staffed by no more than 10 at a time. This summer, at least 85 did, most of them college students, said John Warren, 53, a No More Deaths veteran who coordinates camp staffing.

Ms. Duffy arrived in the desert to volunteer after spending a semester abroad, first on a raspberry farm in the Chilean countryside, and then in the country’s capital, Santiago. She learned about No More Deaths during her sophomore year, in a border-studies course that included visits by the group and other humanitarian organizations.

Mr. Berk, 25, said he discovered the group while searching for work that would get him out of the Brown library, where he had been writing papers about H.I.V. policy. He is thinking about working for a humanitarian medical organization someday, and hoped that his experience at the camp would offer a taste of that.

“Mountains all over,” he whispered as he walked through a thicket of thorny bushes.

“My life is a lot of adults telling me what to do,” Mr. Berk said, spreading his long, lean arms, like a bird in flight. “Here, it’s us, making it happen.”

More Photos

Posted in People of Color & Anti-racism | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Join Us

Join the growing Deep Green Resistance movement and help actualize a strategy to save the planet.

There are two ways to get involved with the efforts of the Sonoran chapter of DGR:

1. Join the Chapter

2. Volunteer

Chapter Membership involves participating in activities and organizing work of DGR Sonoran, as well as meeting its unique expectations, including frequency of participation and attendance of group meetings.

Volunteer Membership involves taking on projects suited to your gifts and capacity. Individuals need not meet unique expectations of the local group, including frequency of participation and attendance of group meetings, but must abide by the policies of the broader DGR movement.

See our Joining page for more details.

Contact us if you have any questions:

Phone: (520) 261-8715

E-mail: sonoran@deepgreenresistance.org

 

Posted in Movement Building & Support | Tagged | Leave a comment